LAURA GELLER NEW YORK INKcredible Gel Eyeliner - Blackbird - Waterproof Smudge-proof Eyeliner Pencil - Built in Sharpener

This is my favorite eyeliner. It is great for mature eyelids as it goes on smoothly and doesn't tug. I have been using for years

No review needed. All ok

I LOVE the easy application of this eyeliner and have ordered it in three colours. Don’t know about the longevity of it yet.

Good product.

Works great!

It smears and travels down your face. Great color

Prior to a special event awhile back, I tried almost every make-up line available at that time, and found one that worked best for my skin tone, skin type, etc. I’ve been using THAT product ever since. I decided to try Laura Geller products because in the ads they looked so natural, and so far each item I’ve tried has been great, and natural-looking. I feel enhanced, instead of “made up”, and I don’t feel the products on my skin. Lately I’ve had trouble with eye irritation from various eye shadows and liners, which I haven’t had with the Laura Geller line. The products all stay where you put them, although they ARE bendable during application. The liner didn’t “melt” under my eyes, which I loved!

I have 2 of these in different colors and it is as though they are entirely different products. The beige one is soft and creamy, goes on like a dream, and the color lasts. The brown one is hard, difficult to impossible to apply and just doesn't transfer any color from the pencil. Don't know if I got a bad one, or if there is just that must variablity in quality or between different colors? Too expensive to keep trying to find out!