Grumpy Butcher New York Strip Steaks, 4 Pack

It was a total impulse buy, but I’m so glad I went for it! Arrived the next day, well packed to stay cold.. I thawed one for dinner and cooked it in a hot skillet with olive oil, using my seasoning. 5 min on one side, 3 on the other and got a perfect crust. Let it rest for a minute, then we split it after a quick discussion on who got which half. It was just perfect. Tender, buttery and full of flavor, just like a high quality NY Strip. We had it with roasted vegetables and a big pot of herbed, buttered mashed potatoes. Honestly, I shouldn’t have second-guessed this purchase. Everything about it was excellent, and I’ll definitely be ordering more!

I ordered 8 strip steaks. The meat was more tender than filet mignon, very fresh, lightning fast shipping and at a decent price. One or two minor gripes tho - they came packaged 4 steaks to a package partially frozen while I prefer individually wrapped steaks. Also, one package of 4 steaks appeared to be a tangled mess of cut meat rather than "steak" steaks. It's still delicious but if I saw the presentation in local butcher shop I would have passed it by.

Although New York strip steaks are not at the top of my steak list (I'm a steak snob), I bought the grumpy's strips because they were on promo and, boy, they were seriously good. Thick enough (but not too thick to quickly sear), very tender (competing with filet mignons), well marbled (but not too fatty), moderately priced (but not cheap $10 steak at a local store or some overpriced steaks on Amazon). Just bring them to room temp before cooking, add coarse salt and some black pepper, heat your pan good (don't need cast iron for these strips) and pan sear them on high for 2 minutes per side. Don't forget to let them rest for 5-7 minutes!

All the “prime” steaks from this box are the worst example of prime I have ever seen. Not worth the cost at all to have this delivered. Almost 0 marbling in each of these cuts. 10/10 will never purchase from Grumpy Butcher again.

The product of New York Steak strips were extremely inconsistent.The large cut & different sizes seemed more like a cut from a Rump Roast rather than a precise cut of a New York Strip Steak The Butcher was definitely Grumpy on this day.This is my first & final order.Quality over Quantity always.

They were good. They had a different taste and texture than we have ever tasted. Don't think I'll ever buy again .

So worth the buy. Excellent knives, sharp and they do a very good job at cutting my meat. We buy beef in bulk and slice our own steaks & such. These knives do the trick. They do a great job at slicing.

Bought these Grumpy Butcher strip steaks for a weekend dinner and seared them in a cast iron skillet—3 minutes per side, then rested for a few. The marbling was spot on, and they stayed tender even cooked to medium, which my wife prefers. Our neighbor popped by for a drink and ended up finishing a steak too—he couldn’t stop raving. Only nitpick: I wish the thickness was a bit more consistent across the pack to allow for universall doness, but flavor and quality were definitely there.