SmartBones SmartSticks with Real Peanut Butter 10 Count, Rawhide-Free Chews for Dogs

So I gave these 5 stars for flavor... Haven't tried them personally but my dogs love them. Also gave them 5 stars for longevity, they are a quick treat for a pit bull but my other dog I adopted doesn't have teeth. He gnaws on one for awhile with a wagging tail. They smell pretty bad when out of the package but unlike bully sticks or pigs ears the smell doesn't remain. They are a great treat, two happy dogs favorite.

I got these for my dog and she enjoyed them a little (even though I had to break them up to smaller portions for her) but she stopped eating them as she is very picking and elderly so she prefers soft foods. However, the other dogs who I gave the left overs to enjoyed them greatly and wanted more!

Great value for a tasty chew for my 14 year old dog. Not too stiff for her to eat. She grabs it so fast, I know she likes them.

We save these for special times due to the cost. Our dog loves them.

One dog likes them, one loves to hide them.

Longevity shouldn't even figure in this one, because if they are great, they won't last, and if your dog looks at it and gives you this 'WTF, Mom?" look, it will last forever. Three of my four Chows love them, and my fourth is THAT Chow.

These don’t last super long for my dogs but they love them and they don’t smell bad.

I bought a package of these on a whim. I give my dog a treat most afternoons, so I thought I'd try this one.And Django LOVED it. He got interested in the other sausage-like treat, but for this one he gets frantically overjoyed.Of course, your dog results may differ. But these are worth a try!