4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara Waterproof, Long Lasting Eyelash Mascara, Smudge-Proof, Natural Thickening, Lengthening, Volumizing, Clump-Free Application, Black

I like what this product does. It does extend my lashes. My lashes are very short. So this makes it look extremely long,But it is NOT waterproofThis is why I bought the mascara because it says waterproof but it really isn't.I've cried and sweat with this mascara and it was all over my eyelids. Very embarrassing when you don't look in the mirror for a long time and no one tells you your eyes are smudged black.So if you are not too worried about the waterproof part, I recommend it but if you are looking for waterproof mascara, this is not the product for you.

If you’re not an experienced mascara user, don’t even try. I wear make up every day and have rather sparse eyelashes. This mascara was lengthening but didn’t provide the volume i was looking for.Hard to work with, a bit gloppy, and make sure you’ve got a good make up remover on hand. It comes off in chunks.I will say the wand is terrific. Even has a built in lash separator in the crown lid! When I gave up on this mascara I cleaned the wand and kept it to use with my regular mascara.

I love this mascara. I have sensitive eyes and this doesn’t bother me. It does make my eyelashes look long and thick. I was bummed when I though Amazon stopped selling it, but just noticed it’s back - guess it was out of stock. Now the down fall is it hard to take off but found that Clinique eye remover works perfect.

I only used this a couple times, because I don’t wear waterproof everyday. When I pulled the wand out, it was broken and the part that drags the excess off wasn’t there. It was in the top section and no way to get it out. Way too much mascara in the wand to attempt to apply it in my lashes.

I am in love with this mascara! I run and swim in it. It's very waterproof, and comes off very easily with a carrier oil or facial cleanser. I talked my best friend into purchasing a tube, and now she loves it as well!

I had terrible experience with this mascara. I was promote to buy this product because the excellent review and affordable price. However, this never meed my needs. It's hard to make this on my eyelashes, they are look over make up which give me a strange feeling/looking. I managed to make it looks ok by about a hour of work. What was worse, during the night, I notice this is very hard to wash off. I'm in danger of making my own eyelash fall off.

This felt like the tar that used to be used on roofs and globbed on my eyelashes in a way that was hard to get off.Couldn't use it at all. Maybe it was was just old. But it shouldn't be sold after a point if that is the problem.

Very nice mascara- dangerous and messy to use with the applicator brush. The brush was so large, I got mascara all over me. Also poked myself in the eye with it. Very clumsy for me.