Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil – 12‑Pack Smudge‑Proof, Long‑Lasting & Hypoallergenic Professional Makeup Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes

I want women to know that I have been buying the $19 eyeliner (Visanti) for over 3 years. I tried the Nabi, on a whim, after wanting to find something else and not spend that much money for an eyeliner. The great thing about Nabi, is that you get so many for such a low price and it works even better. The glide is smoother, its non irritating, it has a deep rich color, and it spreads easier to me. I love this liner, and I will never buy anything else. Just try it and you will see, its the best eye liner that you will ever use. Joan

I've been buying and using these for years and while they are definitely not waterproof or smudge proof, they are excellent. Smooth, rich color that goes on easily. This is definitely the best deal in town.

It's a good price for a bundle of eyeliner. Love that it's waterproof.

Very Smooth easy application and a great true black color. Would give five stars but it says it s waterproof and it is not!!! You get half moon eye lids and it rubs off. As a non waterproof it is great. Great value and easy to use.

honestly its a basic black twist eyeliner. it is a true black. do not twist it up too high or it will break ! i use it in my water line almost everyday and i have one complaint, its waterproof and not smudge proof. it does not last 100% all day so throughout the day i would have to wipe the outer corners of my eye. ONE THING TO NOTE IT IS THE SOFTEST EYELINER IVE EVER USED. do not try and use this on your eye lids CAUSE IT DOES NOT DRY DOWN and you will have transfer! its perfectly size so I can literally just throw it into my server apron or my purse. i recommend this cause its not the perfect eyeliner but it gets the job done

Love these eyeliner, very soft and last long very black and glides on in 1 layer .No irritation especially since I have sensitive dry eyes diagnosed.

First, it is not hypoallergenic. My eyes were very itchy and teary from wearing this eyeliner. Second, it smudge horrific. Third, the eyeliner dries up fast so, it is difficult to use the next times once it's opened. You don't need 10 bad ones. You just need one 1 good one. Beware you cannot return this product.

Easy to use. Great value.