LOKFAR 2 Pcs Black Gel Cream Eyeliner Set, Tool Smudge Proof and Waterproof Matte Black Eye-liner Pencil Tattoo Eyeliner Pen Stick Makeup for Women

Smudge proof goes on with ease and saves time I will always buy this eyeliner this is exceptional product

I liked the idea of this eyeliner, it’s shape and color density. This smears everywhere with very little activity. Wasn’t sure how to sharpen. I certainly don’t need 2 of these I will not use.

I love the lipstick -like design. I hate sharpening pencils or not know how much is left. My only complaint is that there is nothing smudge-proof about it. It's constantly getting on my eyelids and if I so much as graze it it smears across my face. Also, not sure how it's going to keep a point or how you can use it when it gets down to the thick part....

This stuff is not smudge proof. I put it on my bottom eyelash area and literally an hour later I had raccoon eyes.

Disappointed smears all over. I put it on by afternoon I looked like a clown.