Revlon Pencil Eyeliner, ColorStay 2-in-1 Eye Makeup,Waterproof, Longwearing with Smudge Brush, Angled Kajal Eyeliner, 101 Onyx, 0.01 Oz

As a more mature woman, I want to make sure my eyeliner doesn't look tatoo'd (must blend edges!) This liner is easy to apply, doesn't pull on my skin. I like the brush to blend, color does not bleed into my eye creases. Caps are not tight fitting, already lost the brush cap (And I want to be sure the other cap stays on for fear that the eyeliner will dry out). Otherwise the eyeliner itself is one of my favorite!

I like this better than any liquid liner or pencil I have used. It goes on very smoothly and (I think) looks better than harsh color liquid. I hold it one direction for one eye and the other direction for the other eye. It can make a thinner line under the lower lashes. The smudge works for me better on the under eye than the lid. I can't seem to get to smudge between my eyelashes so I have to put some on under the upper lid and then smudge upward. I can wipe away what I don't want with a Q-tip. Stays on all day. Comes off with waterproof makeup remover. I use Fig, which is a nice deep brown. Doesn't last a long time. Have to replace often. But got it at a very good price from this seller.

Glides on smoothly, highly pigmented, and the included brush helps to create a nice Smokey eye. I don’t usually spend much if any time on applying makeup. This is great because I can very quickly apply a little bit or a lot of liner, and use the brush end to perfect the edges and be on my way. It doesn’t quite stay put all day for me, but even the best non-liquid liners have always smudged onto my lower lids by the afternoon. I love this liner and would buy it again.

Went well beyond my expectations, you must not use too much pressure at all and only use a little bit a time to avoid breakage. Next I didn't expect the Evergreen to be so nice but this one really complimented my eyes and I don't usually use greens. I mistook Evergreen for black, but was pleasantly surprised by the texture, color, and quality. I really recommend, it also lasts a long time I swatched it on my leg and it faded but never went away till I wash it off on day 2 in the evening.

The best ever

I first discovered this eyeliner at Walgreens, and I immediately fell in love. The brush makes it soo easy to make a wing or to make a smudgy smokey eye.. a little goes a long way because it does move pretty easily with the brush, but it doesn’t run down my face or spread to my bottom lids. Stays put, lasts long, easy to use. Recently I was unable to find this in stores anymore, so I’m really glad I could find it on Amazon. About to reorder today, I just ran out again.

I barely had the kohl pushed out of the pen and it broke off, in 3 occasions. This transfers very easily and does not stay put like the "ink pen" style Colorstay eyeliner. I ended up with it all over my eyelid and under my waterline. I've purchased this product before with no issues, so maybe the formula has changed.

I adore the color of the Evergreen (more like a Jade) one & the shape of the Angled Kajal applicator tip. However, this is not waterproof & definitely not "color-stay," as it never fully sets - so, if you accidentally rub your eye, it smudges relatively easily. To be fair, I do not have time for a big makeup regimen these days (small tots afoot), so I do not use a primer or setting powder or any of that extra/new step stuff. That said, the traditional Revlon Colorstay 24-hour Eyeliner with the sharpener & smudge stick in the opposite end, in the color Jade (which, ironically, looks more like Evergreen) works much better for staying power & waterproofness, no extra products before/after application needed.