4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara and Eye Pencil Value Pack，Luxuriously Longer，Thicker，Voluminous Eyelashes，Dramatic Extension，Natural Waterproof Smudge-Proof & Long Lasting Charming Eye Makeup ，1 Set，Combo

This set is amazing! The formula is smooth it's buildable, a little bit goes a long way. This made my lashes look as if I was wearing false lashes once you apply it the only way it's coming off is if you remove it. I didn't have to touch up at all (I applied at 5:00a.m. and when I returned home at 6:30 p.m. my eyes looked the same as I left. The packing is BEAUTIFUL! I've used all types of fiber type mascara from Marc Jacobs to Dior and this set works just as well (if not better than those pricy brands) the eyeliner is a perfect pen. I LOVE this. I'm going to purchase another set just to have as a back-up.

The package is pretty but it makes my lashes clump together an look thin the eyeliner seems good but the mascara is messy an stringing blah what a waste of money the seller was nice a refunded my money

I haven't used the eyeliner yet but I am very satisfied with the mascara. It is very long lasting and doesn't seem to smudge as the day goes on. The packaging and the product is presented very nicely. I also received a free gift with my purchase which I had a choice of 3. Customer service was exceptional and sent my gift right away.

The mascara seemed a bit thick and was not easy to put on. It clumped a lot. It stayed on and I had no problems taking it off with makeup remover. Overall it was just ok. I tried it several days with the same results. It didn’t lengthen my lashes like it said it would. I probably will just stick with my Lancôme mascara.

UPDATE: The company sent me a new set due to the eyeliner not working. 5 stars. I love how thin the lines are. Thank you so much!Black mascara is gooey. Eyeliner worked a couple times now seems dried out...

***update***After using this a few times I HATE IT! Changing my review to 1 star. It should be called the heavy tar mascara. It sits super heavy on your eyes, is messy and is NOT pretty at all. I would NEVER buy this again and anyone who loves it has never used a good mascara.I compared it to a cheap new mascara, Essence and it is UNREAL how much better Essence looks.I even tried primer first with this stuff and NOPE.So, it isn't as grand as they play it up to be but for the price I do like it. I don't like it as a stand alone mascara but used with a final coat of my 5d mascara it is great. It is very thick and gooey but dries well and wears great. I will buy it again for sure and the packaging is beautiful.

This product was very thick,goopy,it worked okay at first,but after a couple months,it got dry,and I threw it out. Not worth the price I paid!

To be completely honest I don't think this mascara is any worse or better compared to other much cheaper mascara brands. It applies well and holds good, but again nothing maybellion can't do. The tube it comes in is hella pretty though. That's the best part of it.