Rightline Gear 100J78-B Soft Top Window Storage Bag for Jeep Wrangler JK (2 & 4 door) TJ, LJ, YJ, CJ

UPDATE NOV 2016: I have now used it during an extended period, probably a little over two weeks. The soft JK windows came out fine. There were a couple of minute 2-4 mm divots in a few spots, where maybe the materiel binded during rolling, or where some external force was on it during the two weeks it hung on the back of my JK. But those divots came out - or at least I can't find them anymore! - after a couple days of the windows being put back on the jeep. There were a couple of really bad downpour days and while I wasn't fully exposed driving around in all of it (I would raise the top and move this roll to behind the front seat headrests) this roll did NOT take in any water. While my experience of two weeks constantly being rolled up did not damage my soft windows in any way, something still tells me this is probably not a good idea for long term (all summer long) storage. I cannot put my finger on it and there was nothing but superb performance from it, but personally I just don't think its a good idea for months-long storage. I highly recommend this roll. It would be perfect for a weekend trail where you're not sure if you'll need to put the windows back up if the weather might turn, but you do want to begin the trip topless. This gives you that option/flexibility. I would say that unless you get a really good piece of ground (nice grassy area without many leaves/dirt/wet) it is far more likely that you would be able to move modes from being rolled up to windows unpacked and emplaced on the jeep, rather than moving from windows on the jeep to being rolled up , while on the trail. The latter is not likely in my opinion. It's far easier to unpack this roll on the trail and use your windows, than it would be to try to take off your windows on the trail and roll them up in this. ======================================================================================================== Excellent. I don't know why anyone had a "doesn't work" review. I only used it once and only a trial usage, not done it on the road yet. But so far it works wonderfully! I had previously tried my own homemade solution with fat PVC pipe and batting of fleece fabric from the dry goods store. I was unable to roll the combined materiel small enough to fit into the 6in PVC pipe. Threw my home made failure away and ordered this. It is awesome. The window pockets are superb, cover all three windows perfectly no sticking out. (I have 2016 Wrangler JK.) No problem like with some of the other brands. Following the directions exactly, leaving the rear window's rigid tailgate bar in place, rolling tightly as the instructions say to, it was surprisingly east to get it small enough to fit in the outer case. Easy. The neoprene inners works great. I rolled mine up in the driveway and little grits and grass bits brushed easily off (roll it half turn, brush it off, repeat. Lest you roll up grit into the inside of the next layer.) Other material (fleece, tissue paper, felt, etc) are nigh impossible to get grit and leaf bits out of it. The neoprene is soften ugh not to abrade the window, yet dense and smooth enough that twig bits don't get embedded in it. The only thing I am leery about is the exterior straps and plastic buckles look a little weak like the might not last being cinched tight and at-speed or bouncing the trail, hard. I haven't tried it yet, but that's my opinion looking at it cinch in it in my driveway. I tried to make it tight enough for what I felt would be trail-tight not flapping, but the sewing seam of the exterior strap-to-bag juncture looked like it was going to fail if I cinched it to what I felt necessary. This leads me to think of leaving it up on the folded down top as opposed to any other place such as on top of the roll bar ( branches will rip it off) or behind the front seat headrests ( will flap/bounce too much there, unable to cinch it 2-Gs tight ). For the price in think they could have made the seams beefier, mil-spec "Joe proof". Still, considering the other competitors reviews of shortcomings, this one is STRAC. I especially like the outermost bag, it looks waterproof for all practical purposes. Great product. I recommend it.

Tough material and the interior cloth fabric provides excellent protection for the window panels, rolls up well.

Fits perfect, looks great and helps hold down the soft top when driving down the highway.

I saw this online, and liked the "compactness" of rolling up the Windows for take-along storage. The very first try rolling the window panels, it was a tough job getting them into the storage sleeve, but after I learned how tight I can/should roll the windows it was easy. Yes, the straps on the inner neoprene roll are hard to grab if the buckle is all the way at the end,but it you slide it up an inch before buckling them there is enough strap to grab for tightening after the buckles are fastened closed. The side panels from my Bestop replacement windows are not completely covered by the neoprene -BUT THE "PLASTIC GLASS" IS, protecting the vulnerable part of the window from scratches.So far I have been able to hose the dirt and dust off my new windows before rolling them. I find the best place for keeping the rolled up Windows for take-along storage in my 2006 Wrangler Unlimited is between the back roll bar and the tailgate, before I fold the soft top down. The roll is just the right length to fit inside the tub back there. This does not seem to restrict access through the tailgate any more than the folded down soft top alone would, and I still have unobstructed vision from the rear view mirror. I have not tried any other storage spots on my Jeep, But the attached straps on the outer storage sleeve seem sturdy enough to hold it in place. All in all, I think that this is a great storage solution for the Bestop OEM replacement Windows for my 2006 Unlimited Wrangler, I can't speak for any other brand of side panels, or year/model of Jeep.

Researched all the tops. This seemed the best fit for my needs. I have a 2016 wrangler sahara unlimited with the standard top. FirstIT DOES FIT but you do have to really roll tightly. Took a few tries before i realized that. I was worried about rolling the bar into it as I feel this will add to scratching.?? After a few trip my brand new windows are developing lines around the middle of the back window.Just slight but I'm concerned it will continue. Still better than rolling it up. I'm not sure if it was caused by the plastic on the side windows or the fasteners in the middle or the combination. I always clean my window before i roll them. The roll that the windows zip into seems relatively well made. The cord that fastens around the headrest is a little short and makes clipping it on a little extra challenging but nothing too painful. Either you love the decal on it or not. All in all it seems to work well compared to the competition. My back window fits in with no folding (can't believe that's acceptable), offers protection, snaps on a few different ways and seems well made. Would buy again I think.