2 in 1 Mascara 5x Longer Waterproof Lash Cosmetics Natural Lengthening and Thickening Effect No Clumping Superstrong Magic 4d Silk Fiber for Vibely Mascara Makeup

If applied correctly, this mascara makes my lashes look like falsies. I love the fact that it is somewhat waterproof but still removes with soap and water.

My daughter absolutely loves this mascara and it makes her eyelashes look so long. She loves that it’s a two step and then it has a tubing effect. It came in a two pack and it was well worth it.

I was suspicious of this from the first time i saw an ad on tiktok...but hey, at under $10 I'll try it...with thyroid eye disease and allergies, my eyes are ALWAYS watering. This makes finding a true waterproof mascara a challenge. This one did NOT meet the challenge!!!***But, before I go into this crap more, let me say this for anyone considering this based on the "dual brush" statements:THERE ARE NOT 2 BRUSHES!!!! IT IS ONLY ONE BRUSH!!!!! ONE SINGLE BRUSH!!! STEP 1 JUST PULLS THE BRUSH THROUGH A TUBE WHICH PULLS OFF EXCESS PRODUCT!!! STEP 2 YOU GET ALL OF THE PRODUCT IN ALL ITS GLOOPY STICKY MESSINESS!!!ONE BRUSH PEOPLE, ONLY ONE BRUSH!!!!OPEN IT UP, PULL OUT THE STEP 1 BRUSH....NOW YOU SEE WHAT I MEAN????Ok, now on we go....so using that one single brush....which I prefer to call a spoolie, you apply this crap...and you watch as it smears and drips down your cheeks if you even think of blinking! So now you go on to step 2, where you are going to have more product on that ONE spoolie...apply that..watch it smear and smear and...you getting the picture?I eventually got enough of it to stay on my lashes and I went out...and a breeze blew in my face...and there went my mascara...now I ooked like I was crying tears of ink or tar!To end my rant, I will give this stuff credit for being impossible to remove, from my shirt, my countertop, my washcloth and my sink!!! But on my lashes? Its only toooo happy to come off there!!! Don't fall for the hype given to this crap. Just don't!!! Its nothing but a messy disappointment and one I hope to save others from by not recommending this! The cheapest drugstore mascara will outperform this one!!

It goes on really easy and was long lasting, but for me someone that rubs their eyes a lot it does smudge a bit

Stays on and does not smudge. Works well. Makes my lashes look darker and longer.

I can't give this more stars because of the brush. If you have short lashes this isn’t the right product for us. The brush is too thick and makes a mess at the lash base. I also don't understand the 2 step application when you can just apply 2 coats. Otherwise, I like the mascara's lengthening effects and it lasts all day.

I absolutely love this mascara. It is not only cheap but amazing quality!

Not sold. I watched the TikTok videos and figured I'd try this. Followed the instructions and does no better than your basic mascara. I switched back to KVD mascara as I don' have to spend upwards of 20 minutes putting mascara on with the KVD brand like I do this one. Pretty sure the videos are doctored as everyone using this Vibely shows super long lashes after application.